Representation throughout the Republic of Serbia
Weekdays 09.00 to 17.00, meetings by prior appointment only+381 69 584 0671

What civil litigation looks like, from the claim to the judgment

Složeni spisi predmeta povezani trakom na drvenom stolu
Guides through proceedings5 min read

The eight steps that civil proceedings pass through, what happens at each stage and where time is most often lost.

Civil litigation is a court procedure in which the court decides a dispute between the parties. Such disputes most often concern money, property, contractual relations or the exercise and protection of a right that one party contests against the other.

Although civil proceedings seem complicated to many people, viewed in simplified terms they unfold through a few basic stages. Below we set out the eight steps that most civil proceedings pass through, from the filing of the claim to the judgment becoming final.

1. Preparation before the claim

Before anything is submitted to the court, it is necessary to check whether the claim exists at all, whether it is time-barred and what evidence you have available. It is precisely at this stage that an assessment is made of whether there are grounds for commencing proceedings, what the prospects of success are and whether going to court is justified in the particular case.

Well-conducted preparation can prevent unnecessary proceedings from being commenced and save considerable time and costs. That is why the most important decisions for the further course of the dispute are often taken precisely before the claim is filed.

2. The claim

The claim defines what the claimant seeks from the defendant and on which facts the request is based. As a rule, the court decides within the limits of the relief sought, so it cannot award something the claimant did not ask for.

As a rule, the evidence on which the claim is based is submitted together with the claim, and in accordance with the Court Fees Act a court fee is paid where one is prescribed for the claim.

3. The statement of defence

The court serves the claim on the defendant, who has a time limit to respond to it. This allows the defendant to state a position on the allegations in the claim, contest the relief sought and put forward the facts and evidence supporting the defendant's own allegations.

Special procedural rules apply to small claims. A small claim is a dispute in which the value of the subject matter does not exceed the dinar equivalent of EUR 3,000. In those proceedings a statement of defence is not mandatory as it is in ordinary litigation, but filing one is nevertheless important, because it is the way the defendant sets out a position on the claim and enables the court to become acquainted with it in good time.

4. The preliminary hearing

At the preliminary hearing the disputed issues between the parties are clarified, it is determined which facts will be established and which evidence will be taken, and the case is thereby prepared for the main hearing. The parties are obliged, no later than the close of the preliminary hearing, to put forward all the facts on which they base their requests and to propose the evidence supporting those facts.

After that, procedural preclusion takes effect, which means that a party, as a rule, can no longer put forward new facts or propose new evidence. An exception exists if the party shows it to be probable that, through no fault of its own, it could not have put forward a particular fact or proposed a particular piece of evidence earlier. That is why it is important that all relevant facts and proposals of evidence are put forward in good time, so that the party does not lose the possibility of using them later in the proceedings.

5. The main hearing

At the main hearing evidence is taken, witnesses and the parties are examined, documents and other records are inspected and, where necessary, an expert examination is ordered. The aim is to establish the facts that are relevant to the decision.

6. The judgment

When the court decides on the merits of the claim, the litigation ends with a judgment. The judgment must state reasons, meaning that the court sets out in it why it decided in the way it did.

As a rule, the judgment also decides on the costs of the proceedings. Costs are generally borne by the party that loses the dispute in its entirety, while, where the parties' success is partial, costs may be awarded in proportion to success in the litigation. That is why the way the claim is framed matters, because its scope can directly affect both the assessment of a party's success and the decision on costs.

7. Appeal against the judgment

An appeal, as an ordinary legal remedy, may be lodged against the judgment within the time limit prescribed by law. The appeal is decided by the second-instance court. The judgment becomes final when it can no longer be contested by appeal, that is, when the conditions prescribed by law for this have been met.

If the judgment awards a particular obligation and the debtor does not perform it voluntarily, enforcement proceedings may be commenced, under the conditions prescribed by law, for the compulsory realisation of the claim. Enforcement proceedings are a separate procedure, with their own rules and methods of compulsory enforcement.

Extraordinary legal remedies may be lodged against a final court decision, under the conditions prescribed by law. They serve to review a final decision in situations defined by law. In civil proceedings the most significant extraordinary legal remedies are the petition for review (revizija) and the motion for retrial.

Time in litigation is most often lost because the procedural preconditions for holding a hearing have not been met, particularly due to problems with proper service of documents, timely submissions by the parties and securing the other conditions for holding the scheduled hearing. Considerable time is therefore saved when all the necessary submissions, evidence and documentation, as well as accurate details for service, are delivered to the court and the other party promptly and in proper form.

Practice area

Share

Note. The content of this site is for information only and constitutes general legal information. It is not legal advice, a professional opinion or a recommendation for action in a specific matter. Sending a message through the site does not in itself create a lawyer and client relationship. More in the terms of use.

Aerial view of the Church of Saint Sava and Vračar, with Belgrade stretching to the horizon

A problem understood well
is half solved.

The office represents clients before natural and legal persons, the courts and all other competent authorities. Describe your case briefly and attach the documentation you have. Once it has been reviewed, you can receive a preliminary assessment of the legal situation, an overview of the time limits that matter and a proposal for the next steps.