Representation throughout the Republic of Serbia
Weekdays 09.00 to 17.00, meetings by prior appointment only+381 69 584 0671

Partition of Co-ownership When the Co-owners Do Not Agree

Dvoja stara drvena vrata jedna pored drugih
Real estate and the cadastre3 min read

Physical or civil partition, what the difference is, when the court resorts to one and when to the other, and why partition proceedings in practice most often end in an agreement between the co-owners.

Co-ownership can arise in various ways, but in practice it most often arises through inheritance. It often becomes apparent only after several years that joint ownership by several family members is a serious obstacle to disposing of the property, since an individual co-owner, as a rule, cannot independently take actions concerning the whole property without the consent of the others.

Every co-owner has the right to demand partition of the co-owned thing, and that right is not subject to limitation. Partition can be carried out by agreement, and if the co-owners cannot reach an agreement, judicial partition can be requested.

Two methods

  • Physical partition, the property is divided so that each co-owner receives a corresponding part of it; this occurs when such a partition is possible without a significant reduction in its value or in the possibility of its functional use. This is possible, for example, with a parcel that can be divided into separate functional units, or a house that can be physically divided into separate units with separate entrances.
  • Civil partition, when physical partition is not possible or would lead to a significant reduction in the value of the property, the property is sold and the proceeds are divided among the co-owners in proportion to their co-ownership shares.

What the proceedings look like

Partition of co-owned property is carried out in non-contentious proceedings. The court first establishes who the co-owners are and the size of their co-ownership shares, and then examines how the partition can be carried out. Where necessary, the court orders an expert examination to establish whether physical partition is possible, how it can be done and its effect on the value and functionality of the property, and where needed its market value is also determined.

If, in the course of the non-contentious proceedings, a dispute arises over the right to the property, that is, over who holds the right or what its scope is, the court may stay the proceedings and refer the participant to pursue his right in civil litigation.

Why most partitions are settled by agreement

Judicial civil partition involves the sale of the property, and a public sale does not necessarily produce the price that the co-owners could achieve through an agreed sale on the market. In addition, the proceedings bring additional costs, time and uncertainty for all participants.

For that reason, once the co-owners have considered the consequences of judicial partition, an agreement under which one of the co-owners pays out the others and takes over the whole property often emerges as the more practical solution. In that way one co-owner receives the property, while the others receive the monetary value of their shares, without the need for a sale to a third party and lengthy proceedings.

Before commencing proceedings it is worth talking to all the co-owners and trying to find a solution that suits everyone. A judicial sale does not necessarily mean that the property will be sold at the price the co-owners imagine or consider justified by the market.

Share

Note. The content of this site is for information only and constitutes general legal information. It is not legal advice, a professional opinion or a recommendation for action in a specific matter. Sending a message through the site does not in itself create a lawyer and client relationship. More in the terms of use.

Aerial view of the Church of Saint Sava and Vračar, with Belgrade stretching to the horizon

A problem understood well
is half solved.

The office represents clients before natural and legal persons, the courts and all other competent authorities. Describe your case briefly and attach the documentation you have. Once it has been reviewed, you can receive a preliminary assessment of the legal situation, an overview of the time limits that matter and a proposal for the next steps.